Tight and not sweater material
I'd say I'm usually on the lower end of a medium, and it was pretty tight, especially considering how loose it is on the model. It also barely covered my butt in the back, but that is common for me (I'm 5'8" with a long torso). It definitely does not feel like a sweater. It's more of a corduroy material but with very little stretch.
Response from Lulus.com:
Hello Ashley, thanks for your review! We're sorry to hear that this dress didn't work out for you. At Lulus, we want you to feel comfortable and confident wearing our products. Our team of stylists (lulus.com/customerservice) would be happy to help you find items you love! xo